| The Romantic (10) | Take a villager on a perfect date, or tag along to one. Location and expressions are all-important. |
| The Spouse (10) | Marry a villager, or attend the wedding of another Hero. |
| The Parent (10) | Have a child, or be there for the birth of another Hero's child. |
| The Hunter (5) | Kill a sweet, innocent, fluffy bunny rabbit (remember, safety's off!) |
| The Gargoyle (25) | Find the gargoyles' legendary treasure. |
| The Chicken Kicker (5) | Kick a chicken a good distance, or see one getting kicked. |
| The Cliff Diver (5) | Cliff dive 500 feet, or see another Hero do so. |
| The Workhorse (10) | A Hero must achieve a high-enough chain while performing a job. |
| The Hero of Many Names (5) | Change your Hero's title, or see another Hero change theirs. |
| The Teaser (5) | Make bandits respond to expressions with fear, anger, mirth, and confusion... during combat! |
| The Property Magnate (10) | A property must be sold for twice the price it was bought for. |
| The Rogue (5) | Steal something undetected from a building while there are people nearby, or see another Hero do so. |
| The Illustrated Hero (5) | Tattoo every part of your Hero's body, or see another Hero do so. |
| The Executioner (10) | Sacrifice ten people in the Temple of Shadows, or see another Hero do so. |
| The Gambler (10) | A Hero must win 500 gold at a pub game in one sitting, having tried each game type at least once. |
| The Bigamist (10) | Get married a second time, whilst already married, or attend the second wedding of another Hero. |
| The Swinger (5) | Take part in a debauched bedroom party with several participants. |
| The Pied Piper (10) | Start a party where at least five villagers are dancing, or see another Hero do so. |
| The Party Animal (10) | Get five villagers drunk in under three minutes, or see another Hero do so. |
| The Menace To Society (5) | Commit an act of public indecency, or see another Hero commit one. |
| The Black Knight (10) | Shoot the weapons from a hollow man's hands, blow off his head and then kill him for good! |
| The Duellist (10) | String together a full-speed chain attack, or see another Hero do so. |
| The Sharpshooter (10) | Hit three enemies with one shot, or see another Hero do so. |
| The Archmage (10) | A Hero must kill five human enemies with one spell. |
| The Ruler of Albion (100) | Amass a 2.5 million gold real estate empire, or be there when another Hero does. |
| The Hoarder (25) | Collect every silver key, or see another Hero do so. |
| The Goth (5) | A Hero must dye their hair black, and wear a black outfit and black makeup. |
| The Completionist (50) | Get all expressions, pet tricks and abilities, or see another Hero do so. |
| The Paragon (15) | Reach 100% good or evil, or see another Hero do so. |
| The Extremist (15) | Reach 100% purity or corruption, or see another Hero do so. |
| The Celebrity (50) | Reach 50,000 renown, or see another Hero do so. |
| The Artisan (10) | Succeed at one job to Level 5, or see another Hero do so. |
| The Dollcatcher (10) | Collect all the Hero dolls, or see another Hero collect them. |
| The Muse (5) | Inspire the Bard to compose songs celebrating your great deeds. |
| The Companions (10) | Perform a perfect co-op expression. |
| The Double Threat (10) | Get a co-op combat bonus. |
| The Philanthropist (10) | Send a gift to an Xbox LIVE friend, or watch another Hero send one. |
| The Whippersnapper (25) | A child Hero must collect five gold pieces. |
| The New Hero (50) | The terror of Bower Lake must be defeated. |
| The Hero of Strength (100) | Complete The Hero of Strength. |
| The Hero of Will (100) | Complete The Hero of Will. |
| The Hero of Skill (100) | Complete The Hero of Skill. |
| The Sacrifice (25) | A Hero must choose 'The Needs of the Many'. |
| The Family (25) | A Hero must choose 'The Needs of The Few'. |
| The Egomaniac (25) | A Hero must choose 'The Needs of the One'. |
